James epistle is really an epistle of strawfor it has nothing of the nature of the gospel about it luther, m. Lutheran theologians like to make a distinction between the books of the new testament which were unanimously received as canonical in the early church the socalled homologoumena or undisputed books and the books which were disputed by some the antilegomena. The example of the book of esther is merely one example of many biblical books that martin luther felt free to judge wholly based on his subjective opinion. Luthers treatment of the disputed books ageecreative. Did martin luther deny the canonicity of the book of. Preserved smiths the life and letters of martin luther on page 269.
James was rejected by the ancients, i praise it and consider it a good book, because it sets up no doctrines of men but vigorously promulgates the law of god. The biblical book of james is full of wisdom and is regularly quoted by ministers preaching against gossip the section on taming the tongue in chapter three is powerful stuff. Luther famously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw, purportedly because of its lackluster portrayal of the gospel and the ease with which it might be used to foster doctrines of worksrighteousness. The straw that broke the camels back christian history. Martin luther was born to hans luder or ludher, later luther and his wife margarethe nee lindemann on 10 november 1483 in eisleben, county of mansfeld in the holy roman empire. In fact, luther referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw and sought unsuccessfully to have the entire book removed from sacred scripture. Chasing down the luther quotes about james taylor marshall. Martin luther facts, quotes, timeline, 95 theses, reformation.
Martin luther and the book of james shameless popery. He actually questioned its place in the canon, because he didnt find any gospel in it. James earl ray and the assassination of martin luther king, jr. Pdf james, the book of straw, in reformation biblical. You were not a man of dead faith, but of belief that was alive and active, even at the risk of being rash and god often had his good purposes in your bent to action. Luther and the epistle of straw the calvinist international. James, the book of straw, in reformation biblical exegesis. The roman catholic church appealed to the book of james as the basis for some of its erroneous teaching. Dec 15, 2009 luther thought that the epistle of james was in contradiction to pauls writings, and was not written by the apostle james. Nestingen is the author of numerous books, including martin luther.
The second comments in green made by luther were replaced by other comments that are in maroon in the editions after 1530. Belief in this teaching was one of the major reasons why martin luther rejected the book of james. He also called the epistle of james an epistle of straw because james 2. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. James the straw apostle and martin luther the grit in the. Luther reacted so strongly to the misuse of the book of james by the catholic church that he became somewhat. Nestingen has taught church history at luther seminary in st. He is a nationally recognized luther scholar as well as a popular speaker and lecturer. Its often said that luther was so opposed to the book of james that he suggested it didnt belong in the biblical canon. A look at the most frequently used luther quote on his view of the canon, and luther s subsequent retraction. Martin luthers hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Martin luther november 10, 1483 february 18, 1546 was the first and most distinguishable leader of the great religious revolt of the sixteenth century in germany.
In a word, he james wanted to guard against those who relied on faith without works, but was unequal to the task. It is usually brought forth as proof one must believe an infallible church authored an infallible list of infallible books. Did martin luther repent in his position toward the. A paragraphbyparagraph analysis of luther s preface to the epistle of james.
Historical records and family trees related to james martin. Wengert f or lutherans, james, of all biblical books, isto paraphrase george orwellless equal than others. Why did martin luther discard the book of revelation. Written in the fivehundredth year after the birth of luther, james atkinson here presents a heartfelt argument that the time is ripe not for a possibly divisive celebration of martin luther s break from the roman catholic church, but rather for a completion of luther s work, a fulfillment of reformation goals a reunified, truly catholic church. Jun 29, 2017 theres been a lot of chatter about fr. This author cannot agree with martin luther s assessment of the books of the bible, nor martin luther s personal changes. Some evangelicals get keen on james, but they tend to be the active, ministry minded types who frown on the slackness of the rest of us and like the way james gives us a lashing. Luther called it really an epistle of straw because it had nothing of the nature of the gospel about it. James makes it clear that a persons works are important to his salvation, because he states that faith without works is dead.
James was rejected by the ancients, i praise it and hold it a good book. In the leipzig debate of 1519, roman catholic scholar johann eck used it to challenge martin luther s view of justification by faith alone, insisting that works needed to. He is the author of so youre thinking about going to seminary brazos and the volume editor of 12 samuel, 12. Why did martin luther want to remove the epistle of saint. Now in green are some comments that luther originally made that were in editions of his bible prior to 1530. He also rejected the epistle to the hebrews and the book of revelation.
We can understand how luther would tend to be hesitant about embracing the book of james as the authoritative word of god. Finding jesus in the book of james banner of truth usa. I basically felt like i was the object of a barrage of facts. Mar 16, 2017 brother martin, so well did you embody a life of receiving gods grace. The testing of our faith is like the refining process for gold. Heretic martin luther say s the book of james is an epistle of straw. Luther and the canon of scripture and six points on luther s epistle of straw. The result was that martin luther began to question whether james belonged in the new testament at all. Martin luther s hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Sep 12, 2017 he ultimately branded the epistle of james an epistle of straw that he felt like throwing into the stove and wrote that he doubted that it truly belonged in the bible at all luthers works, e. Those just learning it should not be surprised when they read it, though. After all, in making up his new religion, luther s ultimate recourse was to his own intellect. An augustinian monk, priest, and professor of theology, he launched the protestant reformation and founded the lutheran church.
Luther s biggest issue with the book of james was that it appeared to contradict paul, and it seemed to oppose the doctrine of justification by faith alone, which was a central tenet of the. The recovery of james after martin luther derek cooper derek cooper, ph. Namnet luther kommer ursprungligen fran det tyska namnet lothar. Its written in the style of an academic conference paper and so lacks some pep. But many people know martin luthers opinion of the book, or think they do. Apr 02, 2014 the great protestant reformer, martin luther, infamously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw in his preface to the german new testament. Heres the full context of luther s evaluation from his preface to the new testament.
Martin luther was a man of sin a wolf in sheeps costume glue they wrote this to his friend on august the 1st 1521 quote be a sinner and let your sins be strong but let your trust in christ be stronger and rejoice in christ who is the victor over sin death and the world we will commit sins while we are here for this life is not a place where. It was martin luther who tossed out the seven books considered canonical since the beginning of church history. Six points on luthers epistle of straw james white. Martin luther famously described the book of james as mere straw and would rather it not be in the canon. James has therefore been vindicated by the truth of the word of god. It is usually brought forth as proof one must believe an.
Was martin luthers revision of the bible a return to the. What martin luther said about james though this epistle of st. He famously described james as an epistle of straw, because it talked about law and good deeds rather than faith, the keystone of luther s theology. Luthers treatment of the disputed books of the new testament. Jun, 20 luther famously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw, purportedly because of its lackluster portrayal of the gospel and the ease with which it might be used to foster doctrines of worksrighteousness. Those just learning it should not be surprised when. Although luther never removed it from the canon of scripture, he separated it from what he considered the core of the canon. Therefore st james epistle is really an epistle of straw, compared to these others, for it has nothing of the nature of the gospel about it. James was rejected by the ancients, i praise it and hold it a good book, because it sets up no doctrine of men and lays great stress upon gods law. Martin luther var son till hans luder eller ludher, senare luther 20 och margarethe fodd lindemann. Peters first epistle are the books that show you christ and teach you all that is necessary and salvatory for you to know, even if you were never to see or hear any other book. Luther s canon is the biblical canon attributed to martin luther, which has influenced protestants since the 16thcentury protestant reformation. Did martin luther really want james taken out of the bible. Martin luther, founder of the protestant reformation, referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw.
Martin luther 14831546 martin luther november 10, 1483 february 18, 1546 was a christian theologian and augustinian monk whose teachings inspired the protestant reformation and deeply influenced the doctrines of protestant and other christian traditions. Dec 28, 20 luther famously called it the epistle of straw. Perhaps none of martin luther s writings on the bible are as harsh as what he wrote about the revelation of jesus christ revelation 1. The book of james, which martin luther called the epistle of straw holds a special place in the hearts of those who follow my anabaptist tradition, because it emphasizes treating people well and continues the gospel tradition of gods bias for t. It really is amazing how frequently this citation appears. But luther even quotes james later saying that true faith always shows itself in good works. Vinay mathewistockthinkstock the bible is consistent and plain in its teaching that salvation. The epistle of james has been one of the most misunderstood books of the bible. Luther and the epistle of straw part 2 martin luther held the epistle of james in low esteem in part because, as he saw it, it is flatly against st. The book of james did not teach we are saved by faith as clearly as romans or galatians did. Nestingen was one that i read for work and while i feel like i learned a lot, i dont think it was all that enjoyable. Martin luther s problem with the epistle of straw national catholic register may 10, 2019 the eco straw ecofriendly, ecology, nature, noplastic, world luther removed seven entire books from the old testament, and fought to strip away sections of the new testament as well.
Records may include photos, original documents, family history, relatives, specific dates, locations and full names. Yet, martha moorekeish, associate professor of theology at columbia theological seminary, boldly and clearly replies to such comments that the book of james. What is less well known or talked about, is that luther also praised the book of james in the same preface. Martin luther called the book of james an epistle of straw. Pauls epistles, especially romans, galatians, and ephesians, and st. Nestingen is the author of numerous books, including the faith we hold and editor, with robert kolb, of sources and contexts of the book of concord. After 1530, the first comments in green were removed.
He called the letter of james an epistle of straw, finding little in it that pointed to christ and his saving work. In fact, luther referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw and. But the man who started the protestant reformation, the famous martin luther, said just that. Scholarships singular concentration on luther s criticism of james as an epistle of straw has caused many to overlook luther s sermons on james, the many places where james comes to full expression in luther s writings, and the influence that luther s biblical interpretation had on later interpretations of james. The straw that broke the camels back on october 31, 1517, the day before the feast of all saints, 33yearold martin luther posted theses against the practice of indulgences on the door of the castle church in wittenberg.
James marten is the author of the childrens civil war 3. The epistle of james is no epistle of straw, but instead it advocates building with gold on the foundation of christ and faith. Not most troubling, but perhaps most in need of clarification today among some lutherans and reformed types. Reformation pe rspectives on james 1 timothy george timothy georgeis the founding dean of beeson divinity school of samford university, birmingham, alabama. This scripture must have posed quite a problem for martin luther. Sep 26, 2014 his preface to the book of james was even more negative. Heretic martin luther says the book of james is an. Luthers canon is the biblical canon attributed to martin luther, which has influenced.
One the most popular quotations from luther is the infamous epistle of straw remark, directed at the canonicity of the book of james. Some of the key parts from verses 14 to 26 which martin luther disagreed with are the following. Was luther justified in calling james an epistle of straw. But many people know martin luther s opinion of the book, or think they do, and wonder whether james is really to be placed on the same level as the gospels or pauls letters. His concern certainly came in part because around the midsecond century a. Therefore st james epistle is really an epistle of straw, compared to. What the bible says about james called epistle of straw. Initially luther had a low view of the old testament book of esther and of the new testament books of hebrews, james, jude, and the revelation of john. While the lutheran confessions specifically did not define a canon, it is widely regarded as the canon of the lutheran church. Jul 09, 2009 early in his work as bible lecturer and translator luther expressed doubt as to whether james, hebrews, and revelation are truly apostolic part of the inspired new testament. Many have asked for the reference for luther s quote, which states that st paul and st james stand in contradiction with one another on the doctrine of justification. He called it an epistle of straw, seeing it clearly rejected eternal security.
It is a welldocumented fact that martin luther is quoted as having said that the book of the new testament called james was an epistle of straw. We must keep the commandments and have faith in god. He is the author of john robinson and the english separatist tradition, theology of the reformers, and faithful witness. Nestingen is professor of church history emeritus at luther seminary in saint paul, minnesota. James epistle is a perfect strawepistle compared with them, for it has martin luthers description of the epistle of james changes. Martin luther changed andor discounted 18 books of the bible. Heres the full context of luthers evaluation from his preface to the new testament. Martin luther book of james epistle of straw brian. He called james a straw epistle because he thought james was opposing paul on justification through faith alone.
Yet, the book of james explains just the opposite concerning salvation. Luther made an attempt to remove the books of hebrews, james, jude and revelation. How the catholic church and the lgbt community can enter into a relationship of respect, compassion, and. It appears that martin luther truly preferred the concept of prima luther the primacy of luther and not sola scriptura when it came to doctrine.
Apr 03, 2007 comments off on six points on luthers epistle of straw six points on luthers epistle of straw almost five hundred years after the fact, roman catholics still scrutinize martin luther. His conclusion was that the origin of the book was very hazy and without substancelike. James epistle is a perfect strawepistle compared with them. Vinay mathew istockthinkstock the bible is consistent and plain in its teaching that salvation is a gift from god. If the christian gospel centers in the triune god, why spend time with a new testament book that does not mention the holy spirit. Martinschramm professor of religion luther college. A life 2003 and sources and contexts of the book of concord coeditor, 2001. Luthers canon is the biblical canon attributed to martin luther, which has influenced however, these books are ordered last in the germanlanguage luther bible to this day. Protestant reformer martin luther cogwriter although protestants like to think positively about martin luther because of his supposed belief in sola scriptura the bible alone, the truth is that martin luther changed parts of the bible and discounted the value of many books. I consider that it is not the writing of any apostle. A brief evaluation of his statement on the basis of his own exegesis. Luther, according to the holman bible dictionary, disciples study bible and other references, had the greatest difficulty with what james wrote about faith and works in the second chapter of his book.
1435 748 18 383 1147 406 1388 249 208 1390 601 1356 1375 623 196 913 340 1160 1261 901 214 1210 996 1140 896 1127 696 239 1025 34 1001 1169 1143 333 1060 1254 184 483 1343